The question of whether grinding in games is “bad” is complex. While often criticized, particularly in subscription-based MMOs, it’s not inherently negative. The problem isn’t grinding itself, but how it’s implemented.
The core issue is the perceived manipulation of player time for profit. Many games gate the most engaging content – high-level raids, competitive PvP, challenging story arcs – behind significant grinds. This creates an artificial barrier to entry, forcing players to invest countless hours for access to what should be the game’s most rewarding experiences. It’s effectively paying for enjoyment, not only through the subscription fee but through time investment.
Furthermore, poorly designed grinds are often repetitive and mind-numbingly dull. Instead of feeling rewarding, they become chores. This is exacerbated by games employing predatory practices, such as extremely low drop rates for crucial items, or artificial difficulty spikes designed to extend playtime artificially.
However, well-designed grinding can be a positive element. Consider games like Diablo II or Path of Exile; the power progression through farming and loot acquisition is a core part of the loop, and that loop is designed to be engaging. The key difference? These systems provide consistent feedback and a sense of progress, avoiding the feeling of aimless toil.
- Meaningful progression: Players should clearly see the benefits of their grinding, both visually and mechanically.
- Varied gameplay: Grinding shouldn’t consist solely of repetitive tasks. Well-designed systems incorporate diverse challenges and rewards.
- Player agency: Players should have choices about how they grind, allowing for different playstyles and pacing.
- Fair loot drops and reward systems: Avoid frustratingly low drop rates and unpredictable results.
Ultimately, the difference lies in thoughtful game design. A “bad” grind feels exploitative, designed solely to extract time and money. A “good” grind feels rewarding, integrated into the core gameplay loop, and contributes to a satisfying experience. It’s the difference between a chore and a compelling challenge.
Why are video games so grindy now?
The perceived “grind” in modern video games often stems from a mismatch between player skill and challenge. Once a player masters core mechanics and reaches a point of consistent success, the “flow state”—that optimal experience of challenge and skill—dissipates. They enter a state of boredom, yet the long-term reward structure, be it cosmetic items, power progression, or leaderboard dominance, keeps them engaged. This is a deliberate design choice by developers, leveraging behavioral psychology.
Several factors contribute to this:
- Gating Progression: Artificial scarcity of resources or experience points extends playtime, creating a sense of ongoing accomplishment even if the underlying tasks become repetitive. This is especially prevalent in free-to-play and gacha games.
- Loot Boxes and Microtransactions: The randomized nature of loot boxes and the allure of rare items can significantly amplify the grind, pushing players toward repetitive activities for a chance at desired rewards. This often targets the psychological principle of variable rewards.
- Monetization Strategies: Many games are designed with progression tied to in-game purchases, making grinding feel necessary, or at least incentivized, to compete effectively. This can create a pay-to-win or pay-to-progress dynamic that increases the perceived grind for those who choose not to spend.
- Long-Term Goals: End-game content, such as high-level raids, competitive leaderboards, or the collection of rare items, often requires significant time investment. This sustained commitment, while potentially rewarding, can manifest as a protracted grind to those who only play sporadically.
From a competitive esports perspective, this translates into a dedicated training regimen. The grind becomes a necessary component of skill development, mirroring the rigorous practice schedules of professional athletes. However, the difference lies in the inherent variability of skill improvement. Unlike physical sports where progress is often more linear, video game progression can feel arbitrary due to the aforementioned game design elements. This can lead to burnout and frustration, even for highly skilled players, if not managed effectively through strategic training plans and breaks.
- Efficient Grinding Strategies: High-level players often develop efficient strategies to optimize their grinding, focusing on maximizing reward-per-unit-time. This involves deep knowledge of game mechanics and resource management.
- Community Collaboration: Strategies and information sharing within online communities can help alleviate the perceived grind by providing efficient routes and collaborative approaches to overcome challenging tasks.
What is the progression system in games?
Game progression isn’t just about leveling up; it’s the carefully orchestrated dance of systems designed to keep players engaged. It’s the intricate interplay of challenges (levels, missions, puzzles), mechanics (combat, resource management, crafting), and rewards (loot, experience, story progression) that creates a compelling loop. This loop, fundamentally, is about offering players achievable goals that deliver satisfying outcomes, building towards a larger sense of accomplishment. The key is to maintain a balance – challenges shouldn’t be insurmountable, but neither should they be trivial. Rewards should feel earned, not simply handed out. Consider the pacing: a constant stream of small victories can be just as effective as infrequent, massive ones. Think about different progression models: linear, branching, open-ended – each caters to different player preferences and game designs. Narrative integration is also crucial; the story should unfold organically, complementing the player’s progress, providing context and motivation.
Effective progression fosters a sense of agency – the player feels like their actions matter, driving their progress. This is achieved through clear and informative feedback mechanisms. Players need to understand how their actions impact their capabilities and their journey. Ignoring this leads to frustration and player churn. Consider the skill ceiling: is there room for mastery? For players to continually improve and refine their abilities? A well-designed progression system caters to both casual and hardcore players, offering different paths to achievement and engagement.
Finally, successful progression isn’t just about individual mechanics; it’s about the overall player experience. It’s the feeling of growth, the anticipation of the next challenge, the satisfaction of overcoming obstacles. It’s the engine that drives player retention and ultimately, the game’s success. This requires careful planning, playtesting, and iteration throughout the development cycle.
How can video game designers be ethically responsible when making games?
Let’s be real, ethical game design isn’t some fluffy ideal; it’s about building games that don’t leave players feeling like they’ve been curb-stomped. Diversity isn’t just ticking boxes; it’s crafting believable characters and worlds that resonate with a broad audience, avoiding tired tropes and harmful stereotypes. We’ve all seen the games that feel like a checklist, right?
Healthy gameplay patterns? Forget the endless grind; we’re talking about well-paced progression, rewarding challenges, and avoiding manipulative mechanics designed to bleed players dry. Remember that “one more turn” feeling? That’s good design. Anything that pushes past that is predatory.
Player well-being goes beyond just avoiding graphic content. It’s about building in breaks, avoiding toxic gameplay loops, and considering the impact on mental health. We’ve all had those sessions where we emerge blinking into the sunlight, realizing we’ve spent 12 hours straight locked in a digital world. That’s not healthy.
Responsible innovation means pushing boundaries without sacrificing player agency or fairness. New mechanics should enhance the experience, not exploit it. Think about loot boxes; that’s the antithesis of responsible innovation. Players should feel empowered, not manipulated.
Fostering healthy interactions means actively combating toxicity. Proper moderation, clear reporting mechanisms, and thoughtful community management are crucial. We’ve all been in that online game where a toxic player ruined the fun for everyone. It’s the developer’s job to prevent that.
Exploitative monetization is a plague. Fair pricing, optional cosmetics, and avoiding pay-to-win mechanics are non-negotiable. Nobody likes feeling ripped off after pouring hours into a game.
Protecting the youngest gamers? That’s paramount. Robust parental controls, age-appropriate ratings, and a commitment to filtering harmful content are essential. We need to keep the kiddies safe in our digital worlds.
What are some common ethical violations in graphics and design?
In the realm of game graphics and design, prioritizing personal gain over client needs manifests in several insidious ways, far beyond simple financial incentives. It’s a breach of professional conduct with significant ramifications for the game’s success and player experience.
Examples of Ethical Violations stemming from prioritizing Personal Gain:
- Cutting Corners to Meet Deadlines (for personal benefit): Rushing the design process to free up personal time or pursue other projects compromises quality, potentially leading to bugs, unbalanced gameplay, or aesthetically unappealing assets. This directly harms the client and the player.
- Inflated Billing/Unnecessary Features: Padding invoices with fictitious hours or pushing for features that serve only to increase your personal workload (and thus payment) without demonstrable benefit to the game is a clear ethical violation.
- Using Client Assets for Personal Projects: Repurposing client-commissioned artwork, code, or game mechanics for unrelated projects without explicit permission is a serious breach of trust and intellectual property rights.
- Prioritizing “flashy” over “functional”: Focusing on visually impressive aspects that serve only to highlight your personal skill rather than contribute to the overall gameplay experience. This often results in unintuitive interfaces or aesthetically pleasing but mechanically flawed game elements.
- Ignoring Client Feedback to maintain creative control: While creative vision is valuable, rigidly adhering to your personal preferences over constructive client feedback demonstrates a lack of professionalism and undermines the collaborative nature of game development.
Consequences: These actions erode client trust, damage professional reputation, and may lead to legal repercussions. Ultimately, placing personal gain above the client’s interest produces inferior products and undermines the integrity of the entire game development ecosystem.
Mitigation Strategies: Clearly defined contracts, transparent communication, and a focus on delivering high-quality work that aligns with client needs are crucial for preventing these ethical lapses. Prioritizing long-term professional relationships over short-term gains fosters mutual respect and successful outcomes.
What are the risks of grinding?
Grinding presents a multifaceted risk profile demanding a layered safety approach. The inherent dangers extend beyond the immediately apparent hazards.
Tier 1: Direct Hazards – High Probability, High Severity
- Entanglement: Peripheral speed of grinding wheels/discs creates a significant entanglement hazard, especially loose clothing or long hair. This risk is amplified by centrifugal force, potentially resulting in severe injury or fatality. Consideration should be given to PPE (Personal Protective Equipment) and machine guarding.
- Projectiles: Wheel fracture due to improper use, material defects, or exceeding operational limits can generate high-velocity projectiles. These fragments can cause serious eye injuries or penetrate skin. Regular wheel inspection and adherence to manufacturer specifications are critical.
- Contact with Uncontrolled Grinder: Accidental contact with a spinning wheel or disc, irrespective of a malfunction, can inflict severe lacerations and crushing injuries. Safe operating procedures and proper machine control are paramount.
Tier 2: Secondary Hazards – Moderate Probability, Moderate to High Severity
- Noise-Induced Hearing Loss (NIHL): Prolonged exposure to high-decibel noise is a significant occupational hazard. Hearing protection is mandatory and should be tailored to the specific noise levels present. Regular hearing tests are recommended.
- Electrical Hazards: Electrical shock, particularly with portable grinders, poses a serious risk. Regular inspection of power cords, grounding, and RCDs (Residual Current Devices) are essential.
- Sparks & Hot Metal: Sparks can ignite flammable materials, causing fires or explosions. Hot metal can cause burns. Appropriate fire suppression systems and personal protective equipment are vital. Workspace needs to be free from combustibles.
- Fumes & Toxic Dust: Grinding can generate harmful airborne particles and fumes, depending on the material being processed. Respiratory protection (e.g., respirators with appropriate filters) and local exhaust ventilation are crucial. Regular air quality monitoring is advised.
Tier 3: Indirect Hazards – Lower Probability, Variable Severity
- Slips, Trips & Falls: A cluttered workspace increases the risk of slips, trips, and falls, which can lead to injuries exacerbated by the presence of heavy machinery and sharp objects.
Mitigation Strategies: A comprehensive risk assessment should be conducted, incorporating these hazards and implementing appropriate control measures, including engineering controls (machine guarding, local exhaust ventilation), administrative controls (safe operating procedures, training), and PPE (eye protection, hearing protection, respiratory protection, gloves).
Why are grinding games addictive?
Grinding games tap into our brains’ reward system, specifically the dopamine pathway. It’s not the dopamine itself that’s addictive, but the pursuit of it. The game design meticulously crafts a loop: you perform a repetitive task (grinding), you get a small reward (loot, experience, etc.), your brain releases dopamine, you feel a sense of satisfaction, and you repeat the cycle. This positive reinforcement is incredibly powerful, leading to compulsive behavior.
Many games cleverly layer additional motivators on top of this core dopamine loop. Consider these contributing factors:
- Progression Systems: Clear, visible progress bars, level-ups, and unlocking new content provide constant feedback and a sense of accomplishment, further fueling the dopamine release.
- Social Interaction: Many MMOs leverage social aspects. Grinding with friends or guilds creates a sense of community and shared accomplishment, enhancing the overall experience and making it harder to quit.
- FOMO (Fear Of Missing Out): Limited-time events, rare drops, and competitive leaderboards create pressure to keep grinding, fearing you’ll miss out on exclusive rewards.
- Loot Boxes & Microtransactions: Games often integrate gambling mechanics like loot boxes, which exploit the same reward mechanisms but with unpredictable outcomes, further intensifying the addictive potential.
The key is the interplay of these elements. The core loop of dopamine release combined with sophisticated game design techniques creates an incredibly compelling experience that keeps players engaged, sometimes to the detriment of their well-being. It’s about the relentless chase for that next hit of dopamine, the ever-elusive “one more try” mentality, and the clever manipulation of our inherent psychological desires.
Understanding these mechanics allows for a more mindful approach to gaming. Recognizing the addictive potential can help players set healthy boundaries and avoid unhealthy grinding habits. It’s not about avoiding the fun, but about controlling the experience.
Why gaming is not a waste of time?
Look, let’s be real, the “gaming is a waste of time” argument is outdated. It’s a massive oversimplification. Gaming, done right, is a powerful tool. It’s not just about mindless button-mashing; it’s about strategic thinking, problem-solving, and creative expression.
Mental health? Absolutely. For many, gaming offers a vital escape, a healthy way to de-stress after a long day. Think of it like any other hobby – reading, painting, or going for a run. It provides a crucial mental break and can even improve focus and cognitive skills. Plus, the community aspect – building friendships, collaborating with others in guilds – that’s huge for social interaction and combating loneliness.
Creativity? You bet. Many games demand creativity in problem-solving, storytelling (like in RPGs), or even building things (Minecraft, anyone?). Some games let you express yourself through character customization, level design, or even creating entire mods. It’s a sandbox for your imagination. And let’s not forget the artistic merit of game design itself; it’s a collaborative art form on a massive scale.
Life enrichment? Gaming is a surprisingly rich source of experiences. You explore fantastical worlds, meet diverse characters, learn different historical periods – all virtually, but with real impact on your perspectives and understanding. Furthermore, it improves skills transferable to real life.
- Problem-solving: Games constantly throw challenges at you, forcing you to think critically and find solutions.
- Teamwork and communication: Multiplayer games require collaboration, strategic communication, and understanding different playstyles.
- Time management: Balancing game time with other responsibilities teaches discipline and prioritization.
Growth? Yes, it’s a journey of continuous learning and adaptation. You’re constantly learning new mechanics, strategies, and developing your skills. This applies to both single-player and multiplayer experiences. And those skills? They are surprisingly valuable beyond the digital realm.
So, the next time someone dismisses gaming, remember it’s more than just a pastime. It’s a multifaceted activity offering a wealth of benefits – for your mental health, creativity, and personal growth. It’s an investment in yourself, a way to build a more fulfilling life. It’s not about escaping reality; it’s about enriching it.
Why are the problems of grinding?
Grinding problems? Let’s talk burning. That workpiece charring you’re seeing? It’s usually from an overheated grinding wheel. Think of it like this: you’re generating a LOT of heat during the process.
Common culprits? A wheel that’s too hard is a big one. It’s not shedding material fast enough, causing friction and heat buildup. Too slow a work speed also contributes – less material removal means more time for heat to accumulate. And don’t forget about your coolant! Insufficient flow is a major heat trap.
The fix? Often, it’s as simple as switching to a softer grade wheel. This allows for faster material removal, generating less heat overall. But also check your work speed; a slight increase can make a difference. And absolutely ensure your coolant system is functioning properly – clean nozzles and adequate pressure are crucial. Think of it as a heat-management system. If you’re still struggling, consider adjusting your grinding parameters; lighter cuts and increased speed can also reduce heat.
Pro-tip: Regularly inspect your grinding wheel for glazing or loading. These can significantly reduce its efficiency and increase the likelihood of burning. A dull wheel is a hot wheel!
Why does time go by so fast when I play video games?
Ever wonder why time flies when gaming? It’s all about the flow state. Researchers link the rapid perception of time to the intense focus and excitement of actively pursuing in-game goals. The thrill of overcoming challenges, the anticipation of rewards – these heighten engagement and effectively compress our experience of time. Think of it like this: when deeply engrossed, your brain is so busy processing information and reacting to stimuli that it has less capacity to register the passage of time.
This isn’t just about action games. Any activity that fully captivates you, demanding your attention and skill, can trigger this phenomenon. The key is goal-oriented engagement. The more invested you are, the faster time seems to go.
Another crucial factor is memory bias. Our memories often condense engaging experiences, making them seem shorter than they actually were. Conversely, boring or unpleasant experiences tend to feel longer in retrospect. This difference between real-time perception and post-experience memory is a significant contributor to the “time flies when you’re having fun” effect. The adrenaline and dopamine released during intense gameplay further reinforce this memory compression, leaving you with a feeling that the session was much shorter than it truly was. So, next time you’re wondering where the hours went, remember it’s a combination of intense focus and the way our brains process and store memories.
What is progressive gaming?
Progressive gaming, in the context of esports and competitive gaming, isn’t about slot machines. Instead, think of it as a constantly evolving competitive landscape. Prize pools, similar to progressive jackpots in casinos, grow over time, often fueled by player participation, sponsorships, and tournament organizers’ contributions. This creates a snowball effect, attracting more skilled players, boosting viewership, and increasing the overall prestige of the competition. The more people participate, the bigger the prize pool becomes, mirroring the linked-machine mechanic of traditional progressive jackpots. This dynamic incentivizes continuous engagement and attracts top talent, leading to increasingly high-stakes and exciting matches. The evolution of esports titles and the emergence of new competitive scenes can also be considered a form of progressive gaming, with new and larger tournaments growing out of smaller communities.
Think of it like this: smaller online tournaments build into regional qualifiers, eventually feeding into massive international championships with exponentially larger prize pools. It’s a system of continuous growth and advancement, mirroring the progressive nature of the original concept but applied to the dynamic world of competitive video games.
What are the limitations of grinding?
Yo, what’s up grinders! Let’s talk limitations. Grinding’s a killer technique, but it ain’t all sunshine and rainbows. One major drawback is the limited material removal rate (MRR). Compared to milling or turning, you’re gonna be shaving off material much slower. This directly impacts your throughput – it takes longer to get the job done, which can seriously hurt productivity and efficiency, especially on large-scale projects.
Think about it: you’re essentially using abrasive particles to gradually chip away at the workpiece. This precision comes at a cost: time. So, while the finish is amazing, you gotta factor in that slower MRR when you’re planning your workflow. It’s a trade-off – precision vs. speed. Know your limits!
This slower MRR also affects things like heat generation. While it’s managed with coolant, the lower MRR means more concentrated heat in a smaller area, potentially leading to workpiece damage if you’re not careful. Proper coolant selection and application is key!
Is grinding bad for you?
Grinding, especially severe bruxism, is a serious threat. Think of it as a relentless PvP raid boss targeting your jaw and teeth. Ignoring it is a guaranteed wipe.
The Damage Report:
- Tooth and Jaw Damage: Fractures, chipping, and excessive wear. Consider this a significant debuff to your chewing capabilities and overall dental health. Think of it as losing critical stats.
- Dental Repair Collateral Damage: Existing fillings, crowns, and other restorations are vulnerable. Repairing the damage costs gold (money) and time – resources you could use to optimize your other strategies.
Beyond the Immediate Battlefield:
- Tension Headaches: These are debilitating debuffs affecting your focus and overall performance. Ignoring them leads to further complications.
- Facial and Jaw Pain: This is a persistent, agonizing pain – a constant drain on your stamina. It hampers your ability to focus on more important battles.
Proactive Defense: Early detection and treatment are crucial. Ignoring the early warning signs is suicide. Consult your healer (dentist) immediately. Consider using mitigation strategies like mouthguards (armor) to minimize damage.
What is procing gaming?
Proc, short for “proc chance,” is a crucial mechanic in many games, especially RPGs and MMOs. It describes the probability of a weapon, item, or ability triggering a secondary effect upon hitting an enemy or being used. Think of it as a bonus effect that isn’t guaranteed.
Understanding Proc Chances: The chance is usually expressed as a percentage (e.g., 20% proc chance). This means there’s a 20% probability of the secondary effect activating each time the primary action occurs. It’s not cumulative; it’s a separate roll each time.
Examples:
- A weapon with a “25% chance to bleed on hit” will have a 25% chance to inflict a bleed effect every time it hits an enemy.
- A spell with a “10% chance to stun on use” has a 10% chance to stun the target upon casting.
- Some abilities might proc additional damage, buffs, debuffs, or even unique effects.
Optimizing Procs: Maximizing proc chances is a key strategy in many games. This might involve:
- Gear Selection: Look for gear with higher proc chances or that enhances proc effects.
- Skill Builds: Choose talents and skills that synergize with proc effects or increase their effectiveness.
- Playstyle: Some procs might require specific conditions, like critical hits or specific enemy types, so adapt your play accordingly.
- Understanding diminishing returns: Stacking too many proc chances can lead to diminishing returns, so a balanced approach is best.
Advanced Concepts: Some games have more complex proc systems. For instance, there might be multiple proc effects from a single item or ability, each with its own chance and conditions, often interacting in unexpected ways. Understanding these interactions is key to mastering the game.
Is it healthy to play video games for hours?
Look, hours of gaming? That’s a marathon, not a sprint. It’s not inherently unhealthy, but excessive play? That’s where things get tricky. Your brain gets wired for constant high alert – what they call hyperarousal. It’s not some uniform experience, either. For some, it’s trouble focusing, like trying to land a clutch shot with your aim all over the place. Others struggle with emotional regulation; tilt is real, and it can spill into real life.
Think about it:
- Attention deficit: Missing crucial information, slower reaction times – it impacts performance in-game and out.
- Emotional regulation: That ragequit? It’s a symptom. Uncontrolled emotions can be detrimental.
- Impulse control: Throwing yourself headfirst into a risky play because you’re not thinking clearly.
- Frustration tolerance: A single wipe in a raid doesn’t send you into a meltdown. Managing frustration is key for consistent performance.
Years of high-level competition taught me that pacing yourself is crucial. We have structured training, breaks, and recovery. We don’t just game for hours on end. It’s about finding that balance. Professional gamers understand this; it’s not just about skill, it’s about mental fortitude and self-care. Burning yourself out early isn’t a winning strategy.
Consider this:
- Regular breaks: Short breaks every hour, longer breaks every few hours.
- Sleep hygiene: Prioritize sleep; it’s where your brain recovers and consolidates information.
- Physical activity: Get some exercise; it reduces stress and improves cognitive function.
- Mindfulness techniques: Simple mindfulness exercises can help calm your nervous system.
Does time really fly when you’re having fun?
Ever wonder why time seems to zoom by when you’re having a blast? It’s all about dopamine! Unexpectedly pleasurable experiences trigger a dopamine surge, a neurotransmitter associated with reward and motivation. This surge essentially overclocks your internal clock, making your brain perceive time differently. Think of it like this: your subjective experience of time speeds up, so those fun moments feel longer than they actually are, even though objectively, they may only be a short period. It’s not that time literally speeds up, but your perception of it changes dramatically due to this dopamine rush.
Interesting fact: This effect is also seen with anxiety or fear. High levels of stress hormones can distort time perception, often making stressful situations feel much longer than they are in reality. This is the opposite of the fun, dopamine-driven effect. So, the next time you’re having an amazing experience, remember it’s your brain playing tricks on you, making those precious moments feel even more extended.
Pro-tip: If you want to maximize this effect, try to incorporate novelty and unexpected rewards into your activities. This will boost dopamine release and further enhance your perception of time, making your fun moments even more memorable.
What is progressive gameplay?
Progressive gameplay, at its core, refers to a game design structure where players advance through a series of distinct levels, each presenting a self-contained challenge. Successful completion of a level unlocks the next, creating a linear or semi-linear progression path. This contrasts with open-world or sandbox designs. The “known outcome” aspect is crucial; while individual player skill impacts time and efficiency, the overall objective within each level is predetermined and generally unambiguous. This structure often relies on increasingly difficult challenges, escalating resource requirements, or the introduction of new mechanics to maintain player engagement. Effective progressive gameplay hinges on careful level design, ensuring each level offers a satisfying sense of accomplishment while smoothly introducing new elements and building upon previously learned skills. Poorly implemented progressive gameplay can lead to repetitive or frustrating experiences, characterized by artificial difficulty spikes or a lack of meaningful variation between levels. Successful examples often incorporate thoughtful pacing and a clear sense of narrative progression, tying the level structure directly to the overarching story or theme. Key considerations include level length, challenge scaling, reward systems, and the overall narrative arc’s integration with the level progression. The inherent structure lends itself to established genres like platformers, puzzle games, and many action-adventure titles. However, even within those genres, innovation is crucial to avoid stagnation.
Analyzing progressive gameplay requires examining not just the individual level design but the overall player journey. Are the levels appropriately paced? Do rewards feel substantial and meaningful? Does the game effectively maintain player motivation throughout the progression? Understanding these aspects provides a richer understanding of the game’s design philosophy and its effectiveness in achieving its intended player experience. Furthermore, consider the player agency: does the player feel a genuine sense of accomplishment and progression, or does the progression feel merely procedural?